Written by: Eeman Amjad
Posted on: April 28, 2015 | 
(l-r) Ali Madeeh Hashmi, Intizar Hussain, Arfa Syeda and Zaheda Hina
According to Intizar Hussain, the four eminent Urdu short story writers were Manto, Krishan Chandar, Bedi and Ismat Chughtai. Chughtai, out of all these names, was the most controversial; she received more criticism for one short story than Manto did collectively for all his stories. Hussain asserted that in every culture it was the women who protected the language, and Chughtai’s was the most prominent female voice in this genre. He acknowledged Rashid Jahan as the first female Urdu writer to challenge conventions and question male privilege, but her activism overshadowed her writings. He then compared Chughtai’s writings to those by Qurratulain Hyder, stating that while Hyder venerated every member of her family, Chughtai, on the other hand, spared no one in her writing. Even her own family was subjugated to her pen’s admonition.
“Ismat Chughtai taught us to be proud of being a woman,” Dr. Arfa Sayeda affirmed. She criticized the Lahore Literary Festival for conducting their session on Chughtai in English: “How can the essence of Chughtai be understood in a language that she never wrote in?” She explained that the brilliance of her work was in her simple language, “her writing mirrored the way she spoke, and she never tried to romanticize her writings.” Zaheda Hina recounted stories from Chughtai’s personal life that reflected her determination to stand on par with the men around her. She also quoted Chughtai’s affirmation that she would never have taken up writing if Rashid Jahan had not come before her; both writers created protagonists in their narratives who rejected conventional morality.
The question and answer section reflected on more anecdotes from Chughtai’s life, often highlighting the ingenuity in her wit. One audience member noted that it was time for us to reject the label of Chughtai as a “vulgar and obscene writer”. The moderator concluded the session by reflecting on Chughtai as an individual who encouraged us to change with the times. “When we read her work, we don’t just see the world from her eyes, but from her heart and vision,” Ismat Chughtai was a revolutionary, not only her in writing, but in the way she lived.
You may also like:
Centers of No Attention: Comparing Pakistan's City Centers with European Squares
(November 22, 2024)
